💭 Motion Statistics
Round 1

THBT developing countries should take significant measures to encourage the use of cashless transactions (UPI)

36%
14%
5 Gov wins 2 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
14%
1 Gov veto 4 Opp vetoes
balance inconclusive

THS rise of welfare-to-work schemes (Socialism)

View Info Slide
29%
7%
4 Gov wins 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
7%
29%
2 Gov vetoes 8 Opp vetoes
imbalanced at 10% level

THBT the breaking up of vertically integrated meat companies would do more harm than good to non human animals (Meat)

14%
2 Gov wins 0 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
39%
7%
11 Gov vetoes 2 Opp vetoes
imbalanced at 2% level
Round 2

THW abolish the use of cash bail (Cash)

View Info Slide
7%
13%
1 Gov win 2 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
10%
27%
3 Gov vetoes 8 Opp vetoes
imbalanced at 50% level

In adversarial criminal justice systems, THBT prosecution lawyers should have no obligation to follow the Brady Rule (Brad)

View Info Slide
33%
0 Gov wins 5 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
20%
20%
6 Gov vetoes 6 Opp vetoes
probably balanced

THW require police departments to erase the biometric data (DNA, retina scans, fingerprint collection, etc.) of ex-convicts post serving the sentence. (Koala)

47%
0 Gov wins 7 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
20%
6 Gov vetoes 1 Opp veto
balance inconclusive
Round 3

THR the societal expectation to 'leave a legacy'. (CR7)

31%
0 Gov wins 4 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
31%
1 Gov veto 8 Opp vetoes
balance inconclusive

THBT the "narrative of consistency" does more harm than good. (LM10)

View Info Slide
8%
31%
1 Gov win 4 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
27%
7 Gov vetoes 1 Opp veto
balance inconclusive

THP narratives of cultural relativism to universalism within progressive circles (NM10)

View Info Slide
8%
23%
1 Gov win 3 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
19%
15%
5 Gov vetoes 4 Opp vetoes
balance inconclusive
Round 4

THBT governments should regularly use omnibus legislations to pass major policy agendas. (MyGE?)

View Info Slide
8%
1 Gov win 0 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
42%
11 Gov vetoes 0 Opp vetoes
imbalanced at 0.1% level

THBT snap elections where incumbents win again and further consolidate power do more harm than good (eg Sanae Takaichi in Japan, etc) (OverndOver)

31%
0 Gov wins 4 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
8%
31%
2 Gov vetoes 8 Opp vetoes
imbalanced at 10% level

THW allow citizens to directly vote on impeachment cases through a national referendum (Impeach me)

38%
23%
5 Gov wins 3 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
19%
0 Gov vetoes 5 Opp vetoes
balance inconclusive
Open Quarterfinals

In developing states, THBT governments should mandate majority domestic ownership in all firms operating dual-use digital infrastructure within their jurisdiction. (domestic ownership)

View Info Slide
25%
0 Gov wins 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
38%
25%
3 Gov vetoes 2 Opp vetoes
balance inconclusive

THBT developing states should grant foreign tech firms access to the personal data of their civilians in exchange for infrastructure guarantees. (data access to foreign tech firms)

25%
1 Gov win 0 Opp wins
balance inconclusive
13%
13%
1 Gov veto 1 Opp veto
balance inconclusive

THO legislation shielding AI labs from liability in cases where their models are used by third-parties to cause critical harm (death/injury, property damage, weapons development). (AI labs)

25%
25%
1 Gov win 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
13%
0 Gov vetoes 1 Opp veto
balance inconclusive
Novice Finals

THS the increasing use of invited interventions (full-support)

View Info Slide
100%
0 Gov wins 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
No teams vetoed this motion
Open Semifinals

THR the rise of port leasing agreements in the Horn of Africa (eg those in the port of Berbera, Djibouti, etc.) (Regret-hi-regret)

50%
0 Gov wins 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
25%
0 Gov vetoes 1 Opp veto
balance inconclusive

THBT post-conflict regimes reliant on a dominant armed faction (e.g. scenarios like the HTS in Syria, etc.) should recognise militia autonomy as opposed to attempting rapid centralisation. (itna-belief)

50%
0 Gov wins 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
No teams vetoed this motion
Open Grand Final

Assuming feasibility, THW become God for a day (Noah)

View Info Slide
100%
0 Gov wins 1 Opp win
balance inconclusive
No teams vetoed this motion